Diagrams for Chinese Speakers

I’m very lucky to be learning a bit of Chinese at the same time I teach English.  The process has shown me that many of the tools we use in the West to teach language just don’t cut it for Chinese speakers.  For example, I recently learned that Chinese speakers think of the past as up and the future as down unlike most westerners who imagine the past as behind oneself and the future ahead of oneself.  In Chinese, the term for “last month” combines the words for up and the word for month. This has had a huge impact on the way I plan to demonstrate and diagram tenses for my classes “down” in the future.

Some background:  Chinese students have a great deal of trouble conjugating tenses because their verbs don’t change as tenses change.  They simply add a time word to the verb. So, for example, one hears sentences from students like  “Yesterday I go,” because this makes perfect sense in terms of the construction of their language.

It’s not too difficult to explain to them how to correctly conjugate verbs in the simple past and simple present. But explaining past perfect, present perfect, conditional tenses (subjunctive cases) and other subtle verb conjugations presents a real challenge.

ESL teachers have long used diagrams like the first one below to help students visualize present perfect tense (which, in itself is confusing because the word “present” is used for an action that started in the past.  But can you see how this would be more confusing than saying nothing at all?

Western diagram

Diagram usually used to explain present perfect tense to westerners.

I’m now revising all my diagrams to reflect Chinese up and down thinking. (See the second diagram, below.)  I’ll use different hand gestures, too.

 

tense diagram present perfect for Chinese

2 thoughts on “Diagrams for Chinese Speakers

  1. laurel.erickson

    Dear Toni,

    Very interesting! Wish I had had this explanation when I studied Chinese at UCLA many many years ago!

    Although after reading the maze game of English explained in pictures, I am beginning to think Chinese might be smarter on the diagram level, but really challenging with the many ways something that appears to be the same word can change meaning completely as it rolls off the tongue with different sounds.

    You look fabulous

    All the best.

    Laurel

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *